Carrie Gibson’s El Norte: The Epic and Forgotten Story of Hispanic North America offers a sweeping and meticulously researched history that re-centers the Hispanic experience in the narrative of the United States. Spanning from the early Spanish explorations of the 16th century to the present day, Gibson challenges the traditional Anglo-centric view of American history. She highlights the enduring influence of Hispanic and Catholic cultures on the development of the nation, from the establishment of early settlements in Florida and California to the complex legacies of colonialism and race.​
 
Critics have praised Gibson for her thorough scholarship and engaging storytelling. The Guardian lauds the book as an "epic and timely history," noting that it serves as a corrective to the often overlooked contributions of Spanish pioneers and Native Americans in the shaping of the United States. Similarly, Foreign Affairs commends Gibson for her ability to weave together historical events with contemporary issues, making the book both informative and relevant to current discussions on immigration and national identity.